Faithful readers of my blog know that I am a fan of observing people. What follows today is an interview between myself and a gentleman that I have quietly been observing for over a year. And, I have been impressed. Here is a chap whose example day-in and day-out has seeded a great respect for the faith he represents.
I immediately thought of this guy after I read the response to my post regarding my take on the morality of going to war in the middle east - specifically the comment suggesting that the American Christians and the Middle-East Muslims would never be able to understand each other. His personal history, with chapters as an American, a European, and a Muslim make him the perfect interviewee for the topic at hand.
Q: First of all, tell us a little about yourself
A: I am a German citizen with middle eastern roots, was born and raised in Germany and got to experience two cultures during my childhood, namely the German and the Middle Eastern culture. I have been in the US for almost 5 years now and could claim that I do have an idea about the local Utahn culture. I am fluent in Arabic, English and German and I read a lot. I am Muslim, and very important I am a Muslim by choice. By experiencing different cultures one experiences different religions/beliefs since they are predominantly reflected in cultures (there is a reason why in my opinion one of the nicest people in the US are Utahns). I am a scientist and therefore will not answer in any way through what I learned through books or classes rather than through my experience. Alright, I wish to move on to the coming questions!
Q: I have been investigating different views on the morality of going to war, using Iraq as an example. Based off of what you believe God would have us do, what would have been the best response to 9/11?
A: The answer is simple: investigating! In my opinion it would have been investigating the case! Find out WHO exactly was behind it, find out WHY it happened and find out who is supporting it! Then find a solution within the UN and NATO to adequately respond to these actions. This is the prescribed procedure for all humanities since the revelation of laws to humans. And surprisingly this is the procedure that the West is so proud of. A procedure in which every human being has a right to defend himself and a right to speak out! If I were personally attacked by somebody, I do not go and kill the defendants family or destroy their houses or do the defendant any harm. I will go to an unbiased person and let him judge about us according to the standards in which I am living in. This leads to an INVESTIGATION and then this leads to a CONCLUSION which leads to a just RESPONSE - at least according to the system that we are living in. This unfortunately was never the case back in 2001. WHY this happened was never investigated adequately. It was simply, because Muslims hate the west. Therefore a new enemy was found: Islam and particularly anybody who does not agree with western principles, "you are either with us, or with the terrorist" was the saying said by the president right after the attacks.
Q: Do you think that Al-Qaeda has seriously hurt peoples' perception of the Muslim community? I received an email the other day from a relative that compared the few Nobel prizes won by the large world population of Muslims to the many Nobels won by the comparatively small population of Jews... the bigotry was astounding and embarrassing to see. I actually know one or two people who genuinely seem to associate your religion to terrorism focused on ruining the American way of life. I usually respond to them by saying that every Muslim I personally have known has acted better than most Mormons I know... how would you respond to them?
A: In my opinion, Al-Qaeda itself did not hurt peoples' perception of the Muslim community in the world per se! It is the word "Al-Qaeda" that has been hurting it! But then the word nourishes from the west and spreads fear and terror in the west. Confusing, hey? But, let me explain. Everybody has to sit down and think: who or what is the Al-Qaeda? Undoubtedly it is a terrorist group that wants to destroy the West, right? I agree... this would be the definition I would give as well. But then, how big is Al-Qaeda? Let's put it in numbers? How many members do you think does the organization Al-Qaeda have? You undoubtedly would not find more than 10,000 in the entire world! Yep, I did not forget zeros! Ten thousands... so you can read it in words! Even worse... out of these 10,000 you probably have 9,000 people riding horses, crappy cars, and possessing rusty rifles... so you might think I am exaggerating... but think about it. How equipped are these people, how dangerous are they really? So now think further... the mightiest nation in the world, fears 10,000 camel riders 10,000 miles away? Are you seriously considering them a threat to the nation's security? This is exactly what I mean... people don't fear the organization Al-Qaeda, rather than the word Al-Qaeda that terrorizes people all over the world. Therefore I would not say that the organization hurt peoples' perception towards Muslims... but they undoubtedly started it, which is bad enough. So in essence, you are putting the religion Islam and the organization Al-Qaeda in one phrase... which in my opinion is very bad! 1.2 Billion people suffer from an action that are supported by ten thousand people. This is as if I asked you: justify the action of the American so and so that raped, or killed so and so. You would look at me and say are you crazy? Do you think because mister or miss x did so and so... everybody is so? Right? But here I am, confronted with a question that mentions Al-Qaeda and Islam in the same phrase! How ridiculous!!! Talking about Noble Prizes is childish! If the Noble Prize would truely reflect a human achievement without political influence whatsoever, then ask youself why Mahatma Gandi never received one! But here is a hint of the Islamic achievements in science. Everybody, and I mean everybody! has to learn Algebra! Have you ever asked yourself where it came from or who Al-Gaber was... oooh, now it sounds more Arabic putting it in that twist ;)
Q: One reader has commented that the divide between Americans and middle-eastern Muslims, or even European Muslims, is so great that we will never really understand each other. Do you agree?
A: I don't think so. History has proven that it is possible... and if you visit a local mosque and see that in a little tiny building people from all over the world understand the same principles without explanation, you ask yourself why not on a bigger scale. The answer is clear... too much politics too much power possessed people.
Q: I think that many Americans don't understand the way the outside world feels about us. If it were possible to measure what the average German thought about Americans, what do you think they would say about our government and culture? What do you think the average middle-eastern Muslim would say?
A: European's view: Well the answer about the government depends greatly on who is in power. But I can tell you, that the government suffered a lot from its reputation in the last 8 years. But it gains a lot of reputation now. So let's hope it stays like that. As for the culture, I think a lot of people admire the liberty and freedom in the US. However, people think that it has too much patriotism build in its culture.
A: Middle-Eastern View: They love Obama! I am not kidding! Him going to Egypt before visiting European countries just rocked over there! The fact that his second name is Hussain and the fact that his lineage is Islamic affiliated just does good to them! Middle Eastern there admire the "American Way of Life". If they could, they would all pack their luggage tomorrow and join your culture! So think about it and the perception you guys have that people there want to destroy the West! As proof, look at the Emirates, Saudi-Arabia and so on. They are trying to copy your way of life one-to-one! Just Google how many American universities are opening satellite campuses in Qatar! 5 top universities are opening campuses over there... with the exact same syllabus and the same mentors (http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/420/). But of course the Iraq war did destroy a lot of American reputation... but since Obama you guys are on the fly over there... in general at least!
Q: In response to another reader's comments, do you think that providing aid to Muslims in the middle east post-9/11 really would have been negatively received? Why or why not?
A: No I don't think so. But then it depends on, with what intention this help is based on. Because 9/11 was not supported or organized by the 1.2 Billion minus the ten thousand Muslims. Muslims don't need financial aid... the Arabic countries are one of the richest in the world! It is not aid... it is justice in the world by the most powerful nation that was and still is required.
Q: Now that we are really dug into Iraq, what would be the best thing for America to do?
A: That's a complicated question. And if I knew the answer I would nominate myself for being the Foreign minister :) All I can say is, if I get shot then removing the bullet from my body and recovering from it will be a very very painful process, independent of who shot me! All I hope is, that the surgery takes place soon so people can live in peace, maybe not today or in 10 years. But maybe in 50 years! And I do not only mean Iraqis, I mean US soldiers as well as Iraqi civilians!
Q: Finally, earlier this year you were quoted in the newspaper but your words were cropped and taken out of context. I won't do that to you here! Is there anything you would like to share from your Muslim world across the insurmountable cultural divide to the Christian community?
A: First of all ,thank you for letting me write for your blog! I really
appreciate that... maybe President Obama will read this sometime :) and then maybe I will make it to be a member of his administration :) No, seriously thank you! I have a lot to say about what I would love to share, but I don't have that time and you guys are probably
bored anyways. But there is one thing I would love to point out: All these questions asked put me in the defendant's position. Isn't it ridiculous that I have to defend my religion? I had to defend, why we are not terrorists, why Al-
Qaeda is not representing Islam, why I am a Muslim and to prove that I am not a monster that wants to kill and destroy
everybody in my surrounding? Not a single question was asked in which I could just explain how beautiful Islam really is. How I feel being a Muslim from a HUMAN point of view not from Political point of view. Why is it, that everybody is innocent until proven guilty but in the
Muslim case it is guilty until proven innocent?
Note: I think my the interviewee makes an excellent point here. I have invited him, if he wishes, to submit an essay for publishing on the blog outlining his feelings on "...just how beautiful Islam really is," and how he feels about "...being a Muslim from a HUMAN point of view." I think that it would be insightful to all of us.